How to Make Potato Salads

Last updated: August 18, 2025

Quick Reference

General

Best Potato Types: Waxy potatoes (red, fingerling, Yukon) hold shape best
Red Potatoes: Waxy texture, holds shape well, creamy interior
Yukon Gold: Buttery flavor, creamy texture, versatile choice
Fingerling: Small size, firm texture, unique shapes and colors
New Potatoes: Thin skin, waxy flesh, perfect for warm salads
Avoid Russets: Starchy potatoes break apart and become mushy
Classic American: Mayo-based with hard-boiled eggs and celery
German Warm Salad: Vinegar-based with bacon and onions, served warm
French Vinaigrette: Light vinaigrette with herbs and shallots
Mediterranean: Olive oil, lemon, herbs, olives, and feta cheese
Southern Style: Mustard-based with sweet pickles and paprika
Loaded Baked Potato: Bacon, cheese, chives, and sour cream flavors
Base Vegetables: Celery for crunch, onions for bite, bell peppers for color
Protein Additions: Hard-boiled eggs, bacon bits, or ham for heartiness
Dressing Components: Mayonnaise, mustard, vinegar, and seasonings
Fresh Herbs: Parsley, dill, chives, or green onions for brightness
Mushy Potatoes: Use waxy potatoes and don't overcook. Test with fork—should be tender but not falling apart
Bland Flavor: Season potatoes while warm and let salad chill to develop flavors. Taste and adjust seasoning before serving
Watery Salad: Drain potatoes thoroughly and let cool completely before adding dressing
Dry Salad: Add dressing gradually and let salad rest—potatoes absorb liquid over time
Separation: Mayo-based dressings can separate in heat. Keep chilled and stir gently before serving

Timing

Cooking Time: 15-20 minutes for 2-inch pieces until fork-tender
Make-Ahead Time: Best after chilling 2-4 hours for flavors to meld
Food Safety Issues: Keep potato salad cold, don't leave out more than 2 hours, and use within 3-5 days

Safety

Food Safety: Keep chilled and consume within 3-5 days

Checkout our one click shopable recipes

Lentil, Sweet Potato & Kale Salad with Feta

Grilled Vegan Sausage Dogs with Cauliflower "Potato Salad"

Warm Smoked Salmon & Dilly Baby Potato Salad with Avocado

Warm Bacon, Potato, Leek, Goat Cheese & Arugula Salad with Thyme

Warm Broccoli-Potato Salad with White Beans & Creamy Cajun Dressing

Russian Potato Salad with Eggs, Carrots & Peas over Mixed Greens

Lentil, Sweet Potato & Kale Salad

Herbed Red Potato Salad with Capers, Green Onions, Parsley & Dill

Classic potato salad techniques & variations

Choose and Prep Your Potatoes

Select 2-3 pounds of waxy potatoes for best results. Red potatoes are classic with their thin skin and creamy flesh, while Yukon Gold offers buttery flavor. Fingerlings provide interesting shapes and colors. Wash potatoes thoroughly and cut into uniform 2-inch pieces for even cooking. Leave skins on for added texture and nutrition, or peel if you prefer a smoother salad.

Size Consistency

Cut potatoes into uniform pieces so they cook evenly—some pieces finishing before others leads to mushy results

❦

Cook Potatoes Perfectly

Start potatoes in cold, well-salted water to ensure even cooking throughout. Bring to a boil, then reduce heat to maintain a gentle simmer. Cook 15-20 minutes until fork-tender but still holding their shape. Test with a fork—it should pierce easily but the potato shouldn't fall apart. Drain immediately and spread on a baking sheet to cool quickly and prevent overcooking.

Salt the Water

Use generously salted water (like seawater) to season potatoes from the inside out—this creates better flavor than just surface seasoning

❦

Prepare Supporting Ingredients

While potatoes cool, prep your mix-ins. Hard-boil eggs and chop when cool. Dice celery for crunch, finely chop onions (red for color, yellow for classic flavor), and prep any additional vegetables like bell peppers or pickles. Cook and crumble bacon if using. Having everything ready ensures smooth assembly once potatoes are cool.

Texture Balance

Include ingredients with different textures—creamy eggs, crunchy celery, and sharp onions create a more interesting salad

❦

Make the Perfect Dressing

For classic American potato salad, combine mayonnaise, yellow mustard, white vinegar, salt, pepper, and a touch of sugar. Start with 3/4 cup mayo for 2 pounds of potatoes and adjust as needed. The dressing should be tangy enough to brighten the potatoes but not overpower them. Taste and adjust seasonings—you want a balance of creamy, tangy, and savory flavors.

Dressing Ratios

Start with less dressing than you think you need—potatoes absorb liquid over time, and you can always add more

❦

Assemble and Chill

Gently fold cooled potatoes with prepared ingredients and dressing. Start with 3/4 of the dressing, mix gently to avoid breaking potatoes, then add more as needed. Season with salt and pepper to taste. Cover and refrigerate for at least 2 hours—this chilling time is crucial for flavors to meld and develop.

Gentle Mixing

Use a large spoon or spatula to fold ingredients together gently—overmixing breaks down potatoes and creates a mushy texture

❦

Final Seasoning and Serving

Before serving, taste and adjust seasonings. Chilled foods often need more salt and acid than when first made. Add fresh herbs like chopped parsley, dill, or chives for color and brightness. Serve chilled and consume within 3-5 days. If the salad seems dry after chilling, stir in a little more mayonnaise or a splash of vinegar.

Last-Minute Freshness

Add fresh herbs just before serving to maintain their bright color and prevent wilting in the salad

✦

Creative variations & international styles

German Warm Potato Salad

This tangy, bacon-studded variation is served warm and uses a vinegar-based dressing instead of mayonnaise. Cook bacon until crispy, reserve fat, and sauté sliced onions in the bacon fat. Create a warm dressing with apple cider vinegar, sugar, mustard, and the bacon drippings. Pour over warm potatoes with bacon and onions. This style is perfect for cooler weather and pairs beautifully with grilled sausages.

Serve Warm

German potato salad is traditionally served warm when the potatoes best absorb the tangy vinegar dressing

❦

Mediterranean Herb Potato Salad

Create a lighter, herb-forward salad with olive oil vinaigrette instead of mayonnaise. Toss warm potatoes with lemon juice, good olive oil, minced garlic, and fresh herbs like oregano, parsley, and mint. Add kalamata olives, crumbled feta cheese, and diced cucumbers. This version is perfect for hot weather and pairs well with grilled fish or lamb.

Quality Ingredients

Use your best olive oil and fresh herbs—since there's no mayo to mask flavors, each ingredient really shines through

❦

Loaded Baked Potato Salad

Combine the flavors of a loaded baked potato in salad form. Mix sour cream with mayonnaise for the base, then add crispy bacon bits, shredded cheddar cheese, and chopped chives. Include some diced jalapeños for heat if desired. This hearty variation is perfect for BBQs and potluck gatherings where you want something indulgent and crowd-pleasing.

Cheese Timing

Add shredded cheese to slightly warm potatoes so it softens and partially melts, creating pockets of creamy richness

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best type of potato for potato salad?

Waxy potatoes like red potatoes, Yukon Gold, or fingerlings work best because they hold their shape after cooking and don't become mushy like starchy russet potatoes.

Should I peel potatoes for potato salad?

It's personal preference, but leaving skins on adds texture, nutrition, and saves time. Red potatoes and new potatoes have particularly tender, flavorful skins that work well in salads.

How long can potato salad sit out?

Potato salad should not sit out at room temperature for more than 2 hours (1 hour if temperature is above 90°F) to prevent bacterial growth. Keep it chilled until serving.

Can I make potato salad ahead of time?

Yes! Potato salad actually improves after chilling for 2-4 hours as flavors meld together. It can be made up to 3 days ahead and stored in the refrigerator.

How do I prevent watery potato salad?

Drain cooked potatoes thoroughly and let them cool completely before adding dressing. Warm potatoes release steam that creates excess moisture in the salad.

Should I add dressing to warm or cold potatoes?

For mayo-based salads, add dressing to cooled potatoes to prevent separation. For vinaigrette-style salads, warm potatoes absorb flavors better, so add dressing while slightly warm.